CICA Appeals and Reviews: Can You Challenge a CICA Decision?

If your CICA claim has been rejected or you’ve been awarded less compensation than expected, you may be able to challenge the decision.

This service is offered nationwide from our Bury, Prestwich and Pendlebury Offices.

If your Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority (CICA) claim has been rejected, or you’ve been awarded less compensation than you believe you deserve, you may be able to challenge the decision.

Many people assume that once the CICA has made a decision, that’s the end of the process. In reality, there are two opportunities to challenge an unfair outcome:

  • A CICA Review
  • A CICA Tribunal Appeal

At GLP Solicitors, we help victims of violent crime challenge incorrect decisions and pursue the compensation they are entitled to.

What Is a CICA Review?

A review is the first step in challenging a CICA decision.

You can ask the CICA to review:

  • A rejected claim
  • A reduced award
  • A decision about your injuries
  • A loss of earnings decision
  • A special expenses decision

The review will be carried out by a different decision-maker within the CICA.

Ask us a question

What If the Review Decision Is Still Wrong?

If you disagree with the review outcome, you may be able to appeal to the First-tier Tribunal. A tribunal is independent from the CICA. The tribunal can:

  • Increase your award
  • Overturn a rejection
  • Award loss of earnings
  • Reconsider medical evidence
  • Review the impact your injuries have had on your ability to work

Appeals and Reviews Criminal Injury Claims

Common Reasons People Appeal a CICA Decision

Many successful appeals involve situations where:

  • The injury has been undervalued
  • Loss of earnings has been refused
  • Important medical Evidence Was Missing
  • The Claim Was Rejected

Why Choose GLP Solicitors for a CICA Appeal?

We understand that victims of violent crime often feel frustrated when a claim is rejected or undervalued. Our team can:

  • Review your decision
  • Gather medical evidence
  • Obtain expert reports
  • Prepare appeal submissions
  • Represent you throughout the process
  • Instruct specialist Counsel where appropriate

FAQs

Can I appeal a CICA decision?

Yes. If you disagree with a CICA decision, you may be able to request a review and then appeal to the First-tier Tribunal.

How long do I have to appeal a CICA award?

Time limits apply and can vary depending on the stage of the process. It is important to seek advice promptly.

Can a tribunal increase my compensation?

Yes. A tribunal can increase compensation if it finds the original decision was incorrect.

What happens at a CICA tribunal?

An independent judge reviews the evidence and decides whether the CICA decision should be changed.

Do I need a solicitor for a CICA appeal?

You are not required to have a solicitor, but legal representation can help ensure all relevant evidence is obtained and presented effectively.

Can I appeal if my CICA claim was rejected?

In many cases, yes. A rejection does not always mean the end of the claim.